Few places capture the heart of Islamorada like The Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar — the legendary bayfront destination known for live music, spectacular sunsets, and the quintessential Keys vibe. And now, for the first time in decades, this iconic Islamorada restaurant for sale represents one of the most significant commercial real estate opportunities in the Florida Keys.
Located at Mile Marker 82 Bayside, The Lorelei sits on more than 5 acres of bayfront property, offering over 1,000 feet of waterfront and 500 feet of Highway frontage. Locals and visitors alike gather here every evening to enjoy open-air dining, cocktails, and live music as the sun sets over Florida Bay.
This sale includes both the real estate and the established business, creating a unique, turnkey opportunity for investors, restaurateurs, or hospitality brands seeking a proven Keys destination with global recognition.
This is not simply a restaurant for sale — it’s a landmark, a gathering place, and the beating heart of Islamorada’s bayside community. See full commercial listing details.
Known as “The Pulse of Islamorada,” The Lorelei has long been the backdrop for countless weddings, fishing tournaments, and community events. It’s one of those rare places that locals call their own while still welcoming visitors from around the world.
This property embodies the authentic Florida Keys experience: laid-back, open-air, and unforgettable. With its combination of land, location, and brand recognition, it stands as a generational investment opportunity in Islamorada commercial real estate.
With ample parking, multiple building rights, and prime bayfront acreage, this property offers both immediate income and long-term potential. Whether you continue the Lorelei legacy or envision a new hospitality concept, there’s room here to grow and expand — all within the most desirable stretch of the Florida Keys.
Additional information, surveys, and financials are available upon request. A signed NDA (Non‑Disclosure Agreement) and Proof of Funds are required prior to release of confidential materials.
The Florida Keys offer unmatched stability, lifestyle appeal, and global brand recognition. With limited developable land and year-round tourism, commercial properties in Islamorada are both rare and highly sought after.
From marinas and restaurants to boutique resorts, business opportunities in Islamorada consistently outperform comparable coastal markets — making this offering particularly noteworthy for serious investors.
As longtime Islamorada residents with over 35 years of real estate experience and more than $700 million in closed sales, The Lindback Team represents the most exclusive listings in the Florida Keys. Our family has deep roots in the community — and we’re proud to bring this once‑in‑a‑lifetime offering to market.
📞 For details, NDA submission, or private showing inquiries:
Contact The Lindback Team
Looking for other investment or commercial listings in the Florida Keys? Visit our Commercial Real Estate Page for current offerings, market insights, and business opportunities across Islamorada and beyond.
